Storage Tank RBI

The process industry is faced with increasing economic pressure and a no-tolerance attitude toward environmental accidents. The presence of a large number of storage tanks containing dangerous products constitutes one of the major risks of pollution. Storage tanks are continuously subjected to environmental effects, unavoidably leading to degradation under the form of a corrosion attack. This degradation causes a gradual loss of material and accumulates over the years, ultimately resulting in complete wall penetration and leak formation. Through a leak, the contained product will pollute soil and groundwater. RBI is well established and widely used in the oil and gas, refining, petrochemical and chemical industries. Internal examination of storage tanks, especially of the floor, is difficult and costly. Prioritizing inspections and repair based on risk can improve reliability by focusing inspection resources on those damage mechanisms driving the tank's risk.

Storage Tank RBI

A criticality assessment was conducted on a Storage Tank Farm in Seabrook Texas. The project involved an RBI assessment of 14 pressure vessels, 2 heat exchangers, 108 storage tanks, 888 piping circuits and 187 relief devices. A total of 17 items were found to have a "High" rating. The distribution of overall criticality ratings for the items in scope is summarized as follows.

DISTRIBUTION OF CRITICALITY RANKINGS
Overall Criticality Category
Equipment Type Equipment Count Component Count High M-H Medium Low
Piping Circuits 888 888 0 117 94 677
Fixed Equipment Components 124 340 15 63 54 208
Relief Devices 187 187 2 42 96 47
Totals 1,199 1,415 17 222 244 932

Seventeen items were in the "High" Criticality category due to a combination of internal and external corrosion. The relief devices are High because of the deterioration potential based in part on last inspection date

Risk Distribution by Damage Mechanism

The following shows the Criticality Matrix for this facility with the number of equipment item components in each block. These represent all of the equipment types included in the study. The Probability of Failure Rankings are on the vertical axis and range from "1" (Very High Probability) to "5" (Very Low Probability). The Consequence of Failure Rankings are on the horizontal axis and range from "A" (Catastrophic) to "E" (Minor).

Combined Risk Distribution
I.C Risk Distribution
E.C Risk Distribution
Environmental Cracking Distribution
Other Damage Mechanism Distribution

Probability of Failure

The following figure separates the probability of failure count by internal corrosion and external corrosion, stress corrosion cracking and other mechanisms. Internal and external corrosion and SCC are the major factors contributing to the higher probabilities.

Probability of Failure by Damage Mechanism

Probability of Failure by Damage Mechanism

Probability Analysis for Pressure Relief Valves

The Criticality Rating considers both the probability and consequence of failure categories. The probability of failure is based on the failure mode "failure to relieve at design pressure", which covers the most important failure scenario. The probability category is established by considering the potential for internal corrosion, fouling and plugging. Credit is given when a rupture disk protects a relief valve. Interviews with operations personnel and reviews of the shop test reports are used to determine the deterioration potential. The potential and the time interval since the last shop overhaul are used to determine a deterioration factor, which is converted directly into a probability of failure category. This study revealed that many of the pressure relief devices were in "like new" (4) condition.

The Probability of Failure Rankings are based on valve history, length of time in service, and the potential for fouling or plugging.

The Consequence Rankings are based on the highest consequence of failure of the protected equipment items.

Relief Device Risk Distribution

Consequence of Failure

Unit Rank Equipment ID Component Reason for HIGH
Bay 19 1 31-19-050-T-050-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 19 2 31-19-050-T-050-01 Roof External Corrosion
Bay 19 3 31-19-052-T-052-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 19 4 31-19-052-T-052-01 Roof External Corrosion
Bay 17 5 31-17-098-T-098-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 04 6 31-04-031-T-031-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 04 7 31-04-030-T-030-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 17 8 31-17-096-T-096-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion

For all components in the study, the consequence analysis was modeled as a release of a fluid from the pressure-containing boundary to the atmosphere. The consequence analysis utilized models that consider flammable, toxic, inert and reactive consequences. The Consequence Ranking Distribution for all components is shown graphically in the following Figure.

Consequence of Failure Distribution

Inspection Work Plan Summary

Inspection plans were generated for all equipment items in the study. Each plan included the Equipment ID, Inspection Priority Ranking, all potential damage mechanisms associated with each item and the suggested inspection method to address each damage mechanism. The following represents the proposed inspection work plan for the highest risk items found in the study. The next step in managing the RBI program in this unit is to follow through the recommended inspections. Then for items found to be in the Higher Criticality Categories, establish a plan for managing them. Some of the items can be addressed very quickly; others have to wait until the next shutdown. The table below lists the HIGH Criticality items, the mechanism responsible for the HIGH Risk and a general inspection recommendation.

Unit Rank Equipment ID Component Reason for HIGH
Bay 19 1 31-19-050-T-050-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 19 2 31-19-050-T-050-01 Roof External Corrosion
Bay 19 3 31-19-052-T-052-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 19 4 31-19-052-T-052-01 Roof External Corrosion
Bay 17 5 31-17-098-T-098-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 04 6 31-04-031-T-031-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 04 7 31-04-030-T-030-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion
Bay 17 8 31-17-096-T-096-01 Storage Tank Shell External Corrosion

Risk Reduction

The following shows the projected risk reduction in dollars per year as a result of focusing inspections on the higher criticality items. For this analysis, it was assumed that the risk reduction would result from addressing the highest 8 (1%) of the fixed equipment items in the study, resulting in a 90% risk reduction of nearly $2,500,000 per year.

Risk Reduction

Conclusion

The above provides insight into the results of an RBI study across a number of fixed equipment asset families, relief devices and piping circuits. In addition to the significant risk reduction delivered ($2.5M annually) from an RBI program, cost savings can be realized by a factor of 50% for vessel inspections and up to 75% for piping inspections. Typical turnarounds can be optimized and internal inspections of less critical assets extended allowing refiners to realize millions in USD in T/A savings.

Related Knowledge

Risk Based Inspection: What To Expect

Significant findings, even after ten years.

Ensuring Lower Life-Cycle Costs by Integrating Maintenance Execution and Reliability Management Work Processes

This presentation demonstrates how integrating maintenance execution and reliability work processes is essential to improving asset conditions and reducing their life-cycle costs.

Time to Value - Asset Integrity Management Delivered, Confidently, Comprehensively and Quickly. An AOC & Intergraph RBI Solution

Delivering knowledge based asset files from the true sources of data - confidently, accurately, electronically, and in half the time.

Implementing RBI in Remote Locations

The importance of understanding risk and the significant value attainable through the implementation of risk based inspection (RBI)

Maintenance Contractor/Owner Partnership: Increased Uptime and Lower Maintenance Costs

This paper demonstrates the success of owner partnerships with their Maintenance Contractor aimed at improving owner uptime, reducing maintenance costs, and minimizing the consequences of failure.

Corporate Reliability Programs - Are They There To Help?

Reliability is the probability that the equipment will perform its intended function when required. This paper examines the realities of improving reliability to have predictable supply chain processes and how this reality must feed the planning process in lieu of assumptions based on very historical and less than optimum performance.

RBI Training Manual

RBI Defined - Risk-Based Inspection (RBI) technology has revolutionized the process industry and its approach to managing the inspection of process plants. It is a unique technology that can provide improvements in safety and production while reducing costs.

Does Your Maintenance Contractor Care For Your Assets?

What more can you do for me? To answer that question correctly, contractors need a broader perspective of asset care. This article shows why maintenance contractors are well positioned to leverage the owners maintenance execution workflow, eliminating defects, controlling bad actors and continually improving asset care work processes and procedures to improve the effectiveness of PM, PdM and CM tasks.

Integrity Operating Windows - Another Tool to Mitigate Risk

What are your reliability goals – NO SURPRISES and more! This presentation analyzes how to Integrity Operating Windows provides yet another tool for mitigating risk.

Mechanical Integrity and Reliability: From Anticipating Failure Modes to Planning

A FMECA study reprioritized the inspection regime leading to a multimillion dollar savings in maintenance costs over a five year period.

Using RBI For Optimizing Turnarounds

Examine how data can be used to project risk across multiple T/A horizons allowing the turnaround planner to prioritize more effective inspections where needed.

Risk Based Asset Management - Delivering and Sustaining Value Across a Mid-Sized Refining Enterprise (RMC-09-45)

The business case developed for an RBI program - realized benefits and how the on-going value of the program is measured

Integrity Operating Windows

As with asset criticality ranking, defining integrity operating windows requires savvy facilitation of the subject matter experts that make up these cross functional teams (CFT). The presentation provides real world examples of what it takes (tasks) to deliver IOWs and the roles and responsibilities of the CFT.

Overview of Reliability Based Mechanical Integrity - Generating Value With RBI

This presentation examines several case studies to show actual measured value delivered from risk based inspection programs at DuPont and Tesoro Refining.

Leveraging the Corporate Asset Management Group/Business Partnership Leading to Improved Plant Productivity

This presentation shows how the Rohm and Haas Asset Management Group (AMG) has provided value for over a decade to improve the company's overall plant productivity, reduce operating costs, and defer substantial capital investment.

Overcoming Barriers to the Implementation of Risk-Based Inspection

Address a variety of barriers that technical decision makers face when considering implementing risk based inspection programs.

Development of a Risk-Based Inspection Implementation Manual

The Materials Institute has developed a manual for implementing risk based inspection programs throughout the process industries.

Implementing and Evergreening RBI in Process Plants

Common sense instructions on RBI value, implementation, design, and maintenance.

Instrument Reliability Manual

This manual applies risk based inspection strategies for managing critical instruments in a chemical plant or refinery based on safety, business interruption and asset damage.

The Integration of Risk-Based Inspection with Real Time Process Data

Even before IOWs became a formal API RAGAGAP, thought leaders like John Aller were discussing the need for operational affects on fixed asset end of life.

Integrating RBMI With Your ERP

Examine how consolidating the master equipment list into SAP, and integrating RBI eliminated $56k in annual costs but more importantly, mitigated human error in something as simple as data entry, that could potentially contribute to a catastrophic event.

Application of a Risk-Based Program to Optimize Relief Valve Maintenance

The presentation describes the RBI model used to predict the deterioration in a pressure relief valve at a given point in time. The result? Ten million USD in savings over the next eight years for this ethylene manufacturer.

A Comparison of Risk Based Inspection With a Conventional API-570 Inspection Program

This paper examines the financial benefits and more importantly, the risk reduction benefits of RBI compared to a conventional API-570 inspection program.

Integrating Risk Based Inspection with Fitness for Purpose

Risk Based Inspection (RBI) was a relatively new technology in 1996. This paper provides some of the earliest benefit analyses for RBI following the completion of the base resource document that eventually became API 580 by one of the same authors of this paper.

A Comparison of Risk-Based and Traditional Inspection Programs

This paper compared the number of TMLs required for a traditional time based inspection program with risk based inspection and the resulting savings.

Using Risk Based Inspection to Focus on Corrosion Under Insulation

This paper discusses how inspecting for CUI could be better refined using a semi-quantitative RBI model.

Risk-Based Inspection, From New Technology to RAGAGEP

This presentation discusses the the transformation of RBI as a base resource document to a Recognized and Generally Accepted Good Engineering Practice.

Integrating Risk Based-Inspection with Fitness for Purpose

Risk Based Inspection (RBI) was a relatively new technology in 1996. This paper provides some of the earliest benefit analyses for RBI following the completion of the base resource document that eventually became API 580 by one of the same authors of this paper.

Base Resource Document on Risk-Based Inspection: API Publication 581

The first edition of API PUBLICATION 581 was released in May 2000. This is the This document provides the ground breaking efforts of John Aller's vision as presented to API in May 1996.

Risk-Based Inspection Methodology for the Petroleum and Petrochemical Industry

This paper represents some of the earlier collaborative efforts of two thought leaders in risk based inspection.

Materials Engineering and Risk Management in Chemical Plant Operations

The Publication discusses a study conducted at a 30 year old ethylene plant to optimize fixed equipment inspection and maintenance strategies prior to and during an upcoming planned shutdown.

Related Services

RBI Implementation and Inspection Planning

AOC has delivered thousands of sustainable RBI programs earning the trust of owner operators.

Damage Mechanism Review / Corrosion Study

One of the most important steps in an RBI project is the corrosion study or damage mechanism review.

End-of-Life, Remaining-Life, and Fitness-for-Service Assessments

When evaluation of inspection results suggest that an asset is near its end of useful life, Fitness for Service evaluations can determine if the asset us suitable for continued operation.

Corrosion Control Planning

Achieving zero corrosion-related loss of primary containment in the refining industry.

Reliability Based Asset Management - AIM for all asset families

Asset Integrity Management for all asset families - Rotating, Electrical, Instrumentation, and Fixed Assets

Related Training

API 580 RBI Training

Is our Risk Based Inspection (RBI) program aligned with the API 580 Recommended Practice?

API 580 RBI Training (Online)

Need to study API Recommended Practice 580 on your own?

API 580 RBI Overview

What impact does Risk Based Inspection (RBI) have on my organization?

Risk Based Inspection (RBI) - A Mechanical Integrity Best Practice

What are your goals for RBI? How will you measure your success? How will you sustain that success?

Reliability Revolution - Measuring the Value of an RBI Program

How does one of the largest chemical manufacturers measure the value of their RBI program?

Value Proposition

Developing the value proposition and business case for an RBI program